Top 10 Best buffalo nickels in 2026

Last Updated - 6/25/2026

🏆Best Choice

Heavenly Metals

Buffalo Nickel Replica 1 oz Pure .999 Copper Round Collectible Jumbo 39mm Coin in Capsule - COA by Heavenly Metals

9.8

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.8

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•99.9% Pure Copper: 1 AVDP oz of fine .999 copper meticulously crafted to the highest quality standards.
•Minted in the USA: Coin measures 39mm in diameter, with a capsule size of 45mm, showcasing American craftsmanship.
•Versatile Gifting Idea: Perfect as a challenge coin or golf ball marker. An excellent gift for birthdays, anniversaries, and special milestones. Suitable for coin collectors, enthusiasts, and anyone interested in unique, themed items.
•Capsule Included: Securely housed in a protective capsule, preserving its lustrous finish and intricate design for lasting appeal.
•COA Included: Each coin comes with a Certificate of Authenticity from Heavenly Metals, guaranteeing its composition, purity, and origin.

View offer on:

$7.99

Check Price

Strugglejewelry

Rooted in Christ The Lord is My Rock, My Fortress, My Deliverer Faith-Based Christian Challenge Coin Bible Verse Gift (Single Coin)

9.7

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.7

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•Unveil the 'ROOTED IN CHRIST' CHALLENGE COIN, an elegantly designed, 1.57" diameter piece, antique bronze-plated, resonating quality, and deep faith. This durable coin is an emblem of divine presence, offering comfort during adversities when carried personally or bestowed upon someone needing encouragement
•With a profound verse from Deuteronomy 31:8 engraved, the coin fosters a tangible bond to the scripture's wisdom. The front displays a grand tree complemented by the inscription "ROOTED IN CHRIST" and the uplifting phrase "THE LORD IS MY ROCK, MY FORTRESS, MY DELIVERER AND MY GOD - PSALM 18:2". The flip side etches a divine assurance: "'THE LORD HIMSELF GOES BEFORE YOU AND WILL BE WITH YOU; HE WILL NEVER LEAVE YOU NOR FORSAKE YOU. DO NOT BE AFRAID; DO NOT BE DISCOURAGED - DEUTERONOMY 31:8"
•This finely detailed Psalm 18:2 challenge coin serves as a discreet yet constant emblem of faith. Designed for portability, it slips easily into your pocket, purse, or backpack, making your conviction travel with you. Alternatively, it can accentuate your desk or tabletop with its symbolic presence
•This intricately designed token transcends the mundane; it is a persistent echo of the Lord as our unshakeable stronghold. In moments of doubt, it stands as a reaffirmation of God's unwavering support
•The Christian challenge coin makes an expressive gift, radiating gratitude, appreciation, or motivation. It is a tangible message to a cherished one that they are accompanied by a benevolent God, affirming that they are never truly alone

View offer on:

$11.99

Check Price

Jig Pro Shop

2 oz .999 Pure Copper Medallion (Buffalo Nickel Design)

9.5

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.5

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•2 oz .999 Pure Copper Medallion
•Comes in a clear vinyl protective presentation sleeve
•Dimensions: Diameter = 47 mm (1.85 in.) Thickness = 4.6 mm (0.04 in.) Gross Weight = 2 Avoirdupois ounces (57.2 grams)
•Several different styles available!
•These make great gifts for friends and family members!

View offer on:

$9.99

Check Price

American Coin Treasures

American Coin Treasures USA Four Most Famous Coins, Genuine Coin Set, Buffalo Nickel, Indian Head Cent, Bicentennial Half Dollar and Quarter, Certificate of Authenticity

9.4

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.4

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•QUALITY & DETAIL - Enjoy the American history that lies in this patriotic coin set. A collector's acrylic houses four authentic United States coins, with a view of the obverse and reverse. All dates are readable on coins and will vary in year and mint mark. Coins are minted by the United States Government. The sonically sealed acrylic measures approximately 5 by 3 inches, a matted card keeps coins securely in place.

View offer on:

$19.95

Check Price

Merrick Mint

Then & Now Buffalo 5-Cent 24K Gold Plated 2-Coin Set - 1930s & 2005 Nickels BOGO

9.2

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.2

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•The Original Buffalo or Indian Head Nickel coins were minted from 1913 to 1938. The Buffalo or Indian Head Nickel is loved by many a coin collector, and for good reason.
•These coins pay homage to the Native American heritage that most all Americans can at least partially call their own.
•The Buffalo nickel would enjoy a good run but would eventually be replaced by the United States current nickel, the Jefferson Nickel. However, in 2005, the US Mint released a 2005 Jefferson Nickel that featured the famous American Buffalo.
•In this set you get both the Genuine Original Buffalo Nickel and the Genuine New Buffalo Nickel. In addition, each coin has been fully layered in Genuine 24 Karat Gold to give both coins that beautiful gold shine.
•Don’t miss your chance to obtain the BUFFALO THEN & NOW NICKEL COLLECTION. BOGO = Buy 1 Set and You Get 2 automatically.

View offer on:

$13.98

Check Price

The United States Mint- Philadelphia, Denver

1-Roll of 40 FULL DATE 1930's Buffalo Nickels

9.1

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.1

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•Buffalo Nickels were minted from 1913-1938...
•FULL date Buffalos are scarce due to their high commerce...
•Most Buffalo Nickels found in circulation in the 1960's were dateless...

View offer on:

$47.89

Check Price

Generic

Genuine Buffalo Nickel (Indian Head) Coin Pendant Necklace With Adjustable Chain

8.9

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.9

/ 10

Great

Main highlights

•Adjustable 24 inch stainless steel chain to eliminate irritation
•A comfortable and supportive bail designed by stained glass masters
•Adds personality to your outfit
•Gift box included

View offer on:

$10.00

Check Price

Cut Coin Jewelry Store

Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Cut Coin Necklace Jewelry Bison Five Cent (1938-D Indian w/Rim)

8.8

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.8

/ 10

Great

Main highlights

•[GENUINE] Each coin is guaranteed over 85 years old, and a real nickel
•[HAND CUT OUT] Each coin has been hand cut out by a master coin cutter.
•[GUARANTEE] You, or any gift recipient, receive a 100%-You-Must-Be-Thrilled-Guarantee. If you're not thrilled, we not thrlled either
•[FREE CHAIN] an 18- or 20-inch chain is included. Chain style may differ from that pictured.
•[USA MADE] coins are cut by master coin cutters in the USA.

View offer on:

$29.50

Check Price

Geruibi

Geruibi Sterling Silver 5 Cent/Buffalo Nickel Border Screw Top Coin Border is suitable for 21.22mm diameter 2mm thickness, Coins Not Included

8.6

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.6

/ 10

Good

Main highlights

•✔✔Works for 5 Cent coins or any 21.22mm*2mm coin
•✔✔100% s925 Solid sterling silver Coin Bezel，The pure silver of 925 does not hurt the skin and is very friendly to sensitive skin，With test report-Coin NOT Included
•✔✔The border pattern means to keep your wealth securely locked away，It can be a Perfect Gift for Boyfriend, Friend, Husband, Dad, Son or any loved ones for any occasion.
•✔✔Complimentary screwdriver for easy opening of the screw top, reusable bezel.
•✔✔Made in China

View offer on:

$25.95

Check Price

J.D.R

Collection of 25 Full Date Indian Head / Buffalo Nickels.

8.5

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.5

/ 10

Good

Main highlights

•Full four-digit date on each coin
•Buffalo nickels are a short, but memorable and iconic coin series
•Buffalo Nickel are a short, yet memorable and iconic coin series
•Four-digit card in each coin

View offer on:

$30.00

Check Price

📊

📈 How we rank

With our cutting-edge technology, we examine thousands of products and retailers, assessing reviews, ratings, trends, and sales rankings to identify what matters most to users like you.

Our team evaluates this data alongside genuine user feedback, merging AI analysis with human insights to provide you with real-time, highly-rated recommendations that empower your decision-making with clarity and confidence.