Top 10 Best pickled herring in 2026

Last Updated - 6/8/2026

🏆Best Choice

Brunswick

Brunswick Sardines in Mustard & Dill Sauce, 3.75 oz Can (Pack of 12) - Boneless Butterflied Sardine Fillets - Wild Caught - 17g Protein per Serving - Gluten Free, Keto Friendly

9.8

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.8

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•WILD CAUGHT SARDINES IN MUSTARD SAUCE: Premium, high-quality canned sardines in mustard and dill sauce will satisfy you when you want a tasty and healthy snack, lunch or dinner
•GOOD SOURCE OF PROTEIN: This 12 pack of 3.75 ounce can of Brunswick Wild Caught Sardine Fillets in Mustard & Dill Sauce contains 17 grams of protein per serving (1 serving per can)
•CONVENIENT PANTRY INGREDIENT: Enjoy a can of wild caught sardines in mustard sauce as a great-tasting, protein-packed seafood snack or as an addition to any pasta or seafood recipe
•PERFECT FOR SEAFOOD RECIPES: Brunswick sardines are the perfect choice for all your favorite seafood recipes and is a great food for those on a ketogenic (keto) diet
•CANNED SARDINES: High-quality Brunswick Sardine Fillets in Mustard & Dill Sauce are keto friendly and gluten free
•SUSTAINABLY MANAGED SOURCES: Our products feature a code you can enter on our Trace My Catch website to learn where and how your seafood was caught, processed and more

View offer on:

$22.44

Check Price

MW Polar

MW Polar Herring in Mustard Sauce, 3.5-Ounce (Pack of 18)

9.7

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.7

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•Polar's Kipper and Herring are produced in a new state-of-the art Green cannery located in Germany
•Polar's Kipper Snack is naturally smoked using a variety of beach wood shavings and contains NO chemical dyes or imitation smoke flavor
•Convenient, easy-to-open container;High Omega 3 Fatty Acids
•Polar's Herring in Sauce are hand packed to ensure the delicate texture of the fillet and filled with a traditional savory sauce to complete any meal

View offer on:

$36.00

Check Price

Appel

Appel Herring in Tomato Sauce 7 Oz Tin (Pack of 5)

9.5

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.5

/ 10

Outstanding

Main highlights

•Appel Herring Fillets in Tomato Sauce 7.05 Oz Tins (Pack of 5)

View offer on:

$27.45

Check Price

Deutsche Kuche

Deutsche Kuche Herring Fillets in Curry Pineapple Sauce, in Mango Pepper Sauce, and in Tomato Sauce 7.05oz 200g (3 Cans)

9.4

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.4

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•Herring Fillets in Curry Pineapple Sauce
•Herring Fillets in Mango Pepper Sauce
•Herring Fillets in Tomato Sauce
•7.05oz/200g per can
•Made in Germany

View offer on:

$19.99

Check Price

MW Polar

MW Polar Herring, Hot Tomato Sauce, 3.53-Ounce (Pack of 18)

9.2

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.2

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•Wild caught herring fillets in hot tomato sauce
•Pack of eighteen, 3.5-ounce units (total of 63 ounces)
•Provides 1.4g Omega-3 fatty acids per serving
•Convenient, easy-to-open container
•Product of Germany

View offer on:

$36.00

Check Price

RugenFisch

Rugenfisch Herring Fillets in Tomato Sauce, 7.05 Ounce

9.1

ChoiceComparer.com Score

9.1

/ 10

Excellent

Main highlights

•Certified sustainable seafood MSC
•Provides Omega 3 Fatty Acids
•BPA free and shelf stable fish
•Product of Germany
•Rugenfisch Herring Fillets in Tomato Sauce

View offer on:

$8.59

Check Price

Appel

Appel Herring Filets in Dill-Kraueter Creme 200 grams (7.05 oz)

8.9

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.9

/ 10

Great

Main highlights

View offer on:

$6.99

$8.99

-22%

Check Price

Alstertor

Alstertor Herring Fillets in Dill-Herb Sauce, 7.05 Ounce (Pack of 10)

8.8

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.8

/ 10

Great

Main highlights

View offer on:

$68.56

Check Price

Blue Hill Bay

Blue Hill Bay, Herring in Dill Marinade, 12 oz

8.6

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.6

/ 10

Good

Main highlights

•Responsibly Farmed or sustainable wild-caught
•Certain preservatives prohibited, including sodium bisulfite and STPP
•Traceable to farm or fishery

View offer on:

Check Price

Blue Hill Bay

Blue Hill Bay, Herring in Wine Sauce, 12 oz

8.5

ChoiceComparer.com Score

8.5

/ 10

Good

Main highlights

•WILD CAUGHT - Wild caught in the pristine waters of Iceland, this preservative free pickled herring is buttery in texture and full of flavor.
•DELICIOUS DELICACY - Our renowned Herring is the ultimate rendition of a classic carefully marinated with premium ingredients to produce a fresh, tender and rich delicacy.
•RESONSIBLY SOURCED - MSC Certified, support Wild fisheries committed to responsible fishing practices with our sustainably sourced herring. Traceable from catch to pack.
•READY TO EAT - Never settle for less than fresh with canned. One bite of our herring on its own, on a bagel or a cracker or as an appetizer paired with crisp white wine - you'll never settle again!
•ZERO Trans Fat, Gluten, LOW in calories, Kosher Certified, Rich in Omega 3's and Protein to support a HEALTHY lifestyle.

View offer on:

Check Price

📊

📈 How we rank

With our cutting-edge technology, we examine thousands of products and retailers, assessing reviews, ratings, trends, and sales rankings to identify what matters most to users like you.

Our team evaluates this data alongside genuine user feedback, merging AI analysis with human insights to provide you with real-time, highly-rated recommendations that empower your decision-making with clarity and confidence.